In Plain View Read online

  “Tell me more about Tom. What was he like?”

  That brought out the smile. “Oh, he liked the animals. The dogs all slept in his room. Barn cat would come to him if he-” She flipped her fingers against her pants, and then again in the air for Ainsley’s benefit, as if she were fluttering hello. “He even made pets of mice.”

  “Mice?” I returned her smile.

  “Thomas could be very…still. Animals appreciate that. But he could move quick, too. Especially, when he was afraid. Then he moved-quick. Without thinking.” Her eyes drifted out of focus as a memory seemed to flash through her mind. Her words stalled.

  “Tell me about a time he moved quick.”

  “I…don’t remember,” she mumbled. A flush spread up her neck into her face.

  “Okay. Tell me about a time he was with the animals.”

  She thought a moment. “He was always in the barn when he was supposed to be working the field. He liked to be around the animals, pet them, curry the horses’ hair. Once, for my birthday, he braided Foxglove’s mane and put flowers in her hair. It was a Sunday. I took her to church that way.”

  “Pretty.”

  “We were punished for it,” she added, matter-of-factly. “Father thought it was prideful, showing off. It is hard for me to turn away from pretty things,” she admitted as if it were a terrible fault.

  My empathy meter kicked into overdrive. I kept flashing back on my own heartfelt confessions: age seven, eight, nine. Bless me, Father, for I have sinned. I lied five times. I broke the glass on purpose…stole the bottle…started the fight.

  “After Thomas left, I missed him greatly. Once I was sixteen, we found a way to meet in the town. He took me to see things. The zoo, the mall, movie theaters. Have you ever been to the O’Hare International Airport?”

  “Yes.”

  “Have you seen the great hall of lights that sing above the moving walkway?”

  That would be the tunnel that connects the two wings of the United Airlines tunnel. There’s a light sculpture above, glowing paneled walls and a new wave music audio track.

  “Yeah, I’ve been there.”

  “Isn’t it wonderful?” Her voice breathed awe. “We spent the whole day at the airport once.”

  “So that was a good day. When was that?”

  “Right after he first went away. Before I finished school.”

  Melton’s research figured Tom had left his Amish home about four years ago. “When did you finish school, Rachel?”

  “When I was thirteen.”

  “Thirteen? What about high school?”

  “It’s not Ordnung,” she said. Absolute is the only way to describe the tone that word invoked.

  “You mentioned Ordnung before. Could you explain it?”

  “Most do not attend high school because it’s not Ordnung, um, not according to the community’s rules.”

  I kept my face blank. “Ah. Well, then the airport was a long time ago. What did you and Tom do more recently?”

  “My father would not be happy that I see Thomas.” She ducked her chin. “Not so much time for trips to the airport these days. We stayed closer to home.”

  “Your father didn’t know you saw Tom?”

  “No.”

  The change was so abrupt, I could almost feel her guilt swell between us, big and dark, swimming right beneath the surface. The small hairs on my arm prickled.

  “It’s not forbidden yet,” she assured me. “I have not been baptized. The rumspringa,” she confided.

  “Sorry, I don’t know.”

  “It’s the time between childhood and being baptized in the community. It is a time between-of adult choosing. I must choose.”

  I looked at the girl sitting in front of me. Reporters have a voice that comes out when they ask the questions that mask a strong opinion. I could hear the voice when I asked her, “How long have you been an adult, Rachel?”

  “Since my sixteenth birthday.”

  “That long?” I said. “But then why were you surprised when I said you could make your own choice about being interviewed at age eighteen?”

  It flustered her. “Well, I may choose to do things that please me, but I must think if they affect others. If others are affected, they ought to be considered. Yes?” She said it with such simple sincerity, we took a minute of silence before I could think of my next question.

  “Makes sense to me. What sort of things did you and Tom do ‘closer to home’?”

  Her eyes flashed up and away. “Oh, things…you know,” she lilted with an elaborate shrug.

  ’Til now, Rachel Jost had reminded me of my farm-raised grandma. Lots of straight talk, in short declarative sentences. We must be getting to the good stuff; Rachel suddenly sounded like a teenager. She glanced past the camera at Ainsley’s bright head, his eyes down, discreetly monitoring the recording.

  “College, is that your stomach I hear again?” I called out. “How about you take a break for a minute and go get all of us some fries?”

  The boy didn’t argue. He nodded, pulled out his ear piece, fiddled with the tripod lock-down and left.

  “Now that we’re a little more private…what sort of ‘you know, things’?”

  Give the girl credit. She didn’t dodge twice. “We have a custom called bundling.”

  “As in keeping warm in winter?”

  She squirmed where she sat. “Between people.”

  “I don’t think I know about that.” After a long silence, I added, “Would you tell me about it?”

  “People…when they are of an age to marry, sometimes… It is good to marry. To have children.”

  “Sure.”

  “And when you think of marrying, it is very important to choose rightly. There is no divorce for us. We remain together until death.”

  “You’d definitely want to choose the right guy.”

  Rachel studied the hole her toe was making in a scruffy tuft of grass. “Sometimes, you must get to know him.”

  “‘Get to know him’? In what way?”

  She met my gaze with a look that was twenty percent guilt and a surprising eighty percent wit. Rachel Jost had a sense of humor.

  “Ah. That way.”

  Neither of us rushed to elaborate.

  I tried again. “You and Tom have been spending time ‘getting to know one another’ to help you decide whether to marry?”

  “Oh, Thomas wanted to marry me,” she admitted, face turned away.

  “But you weren’t sure.”

  Slowly, she brought herself to look at me. Her mouth was pressed tight, holding back words and tears. The effort had mottled her face into a raw blotch.

  Oh shit. Teenagers are a danger to themselves and others. All that emoting from full-grown hearts without any adult-acquired immunity to suffering.

  “Lots of people have trouble being sure,” I said, as if I knew.

  “To marry Thomas,” she began, “and live with him in the world, I would have to accept Meidung-leave my community, leave my father forever. To marry and be Thomas’s-” She seemed to be struggling for the right word.

  “Wife?” I suggested.

  “Amish wife,” she answered firmly. “Then he would have to leave the world forever. How could that be right either?” She looked at me with a helpless expression. “There was a disagreement between us. Thomas thought that more would convince me.” The pain in Rachel’s voice put a kink in my neck.

  “What kind of ‘more’? More time? More money?”

  She looked confused for a moment. “No, no. Can you remember, Miss O’Hara, what it was like before, before you knew there was something else?”

  Riddles inside of riddles, but I didn’t want to interrupt her flow. I shook my head.

  Rachel sighed a little. “I don’t remember anymore, what it was like not wanting to be different, to be with Thomas. Oh, and kissing,” she whispered. “How much easier it would be, not to know. My father says true sin is not done in ignorance. We must have knowledge to sin. I und
erstand now. That’s why Thomas was always between. He knew both worlds. It surrounded him.” Her voice was small as a child’s. “He was lost and he needed me. If my faith had been stronger, perhaps.”

  “You could have saved him?”

  “He asked me to marry him. And I refused him.”

  The kid had eighteen years of experience, an eighth-grade education and some of the damndest questions of the human experience to digest. Twice her age and double her education, I hadn’t come up with anything better than Life Isn’t Fair. As a motto, it wasn’t much comfort. For me or Jenny.

  The only remedy I know is to put the worst into words. “You think Tom killed himself because you wouldn’t marry him?”

  She nodded, so tight lipped I was afraid she might implode. An ill-timed flashback to Jenny’s face this morning caught me in an empathy ambush. I could see it in Rachel’s eyes; she was disappearing down the well-hole. Sinking into crushing, septic darkness. Sometimes, if you throw the right distraction, a person will try to save themselves.

  “People aren’t that easy to control, Rachel. There was more on Tom’s mind than just marrying you. That much I can say for sure.” Thanks to Curzon’s cousin, Tom had been embarrassed at work, reprimanded by his boss and fought with his more-than-a-friend Pat. Rachel was only part of what pushed Jost over the edge. “I’ve got one last question for you.” My voice went cool, enough emotional crap, back to business. “Who owns the binoculars? You, or your dad?”

  “What?” She blinked back into herself.

  “Do you or your father own a pair of long-range binoculars?”

  “No. No,” she said quickly. “I think maybe Mrs. Peachy owns a pair. Her grandson gave them to her for watching birds on the feeder. The bad leg keeps her inside most days.”

  “Ah, right. Does your dad have people helping him with the farm, since Tom left?”

  “Of course. Always.”

  That didn’t narrow down who might have been watching when I took the photo of Tom coming down from the tree. Nothing like real life to keep the story messy. “How could I get your dad to talk to me, Rachel?”

  “Heaven only knows,” she answered quietly. “I don’t. I must go now.”

  Those last minutes of an interview are often awkward. The camera seems to re-materialize. Everyone becomes self-conscious. Most people fumble their farewells. Some shake my hand and ask me to call; some duck and cover. Rachel ran.

  With a quick goodbye, she picked up her clunky boots and walked away. She wouldn’t accept a ride, even halfway. Someone was meeting her in the Walmart parking lot, she knew a short cut, needed to walk. In other words, leave me alone.

  I didn’t push.

  She picked her way across the traffic, carrying the clothes of her other life under her arm. The sun was low and sinking fast. I wondered if she’d make it home before dark.

  Ainsley wandered out across the parking lot. “She gone?”

  “Yeah.” I sat down and made some notes for later.

  Photos: iso Rachel boots? (Juxta. Firehouse boots.)

  Need school house.

  Airport pick-ups? (Stock/news library might carry.)

  Ainsley checked the images before breaking down the tripod.

  “How’d that last bit look? Enough light?” I asked. “Did she stay in frame?”

  “Of course I kept her in frame,” he snorted indignantly.

  “What about after you left?”

  “After I left?” Ainsley repeated. Slowly. “I turned the camera off when I left.”

  “You what?” I felt a sick sort of lurch, the kind you get on a downhill.

  “I thought you wanted privacy.”

  “From you, you bonehead! Not the camera. Never, never from the camera.”

  I sank down onto the picnic bench and tried to give myself the pep talk. It’s not brain surgery. It’s only television. Unfortunately, the you are fucked voice was too loud for me to hear anything reassuring.

  “Sorry,” Ainsley offered, sinking down next to me. “I misunderstood. I didn’t think she’d want to talk on camera if she didn’t want to talk in front of me.”

  “Not again, that’s for sure.”

  “What did we lose?”

  At least he said “we.” “Oh, stuff like she was pretty much sleeping with Tom Jost and if she’d agreed to marry him, he wouldn’t have killed himself.”

  “No way.” He was so full of Disney-earnest shock, the sick feeling in my stomach doubled. “She looks so innocent.”

  “She is innocent.” I couldn’t decide whether to laugh or punch him. This business makes it very clear: what you think you know, based on what you think you see, tells more about who you are, than what you saw.

  “Listen up, College Boy.” I rolled my head and cracked off the tension building in my right cross. “That was one. You get to three, I tell Uncle Richie you and I are breaking up, and you are going back to baby J-school classes. Got it?” Journalism school would beat the impulse for privacy out of him.

  “Yeah. I got it.”

  “Good. Here’s rule numero uno: never, ever turn the camera off. You hear me? You’re walking backward into traffic or running for your life-I don’t give a shit-you keep taking pictures. You work for me, you will die with your finger on the trigger. Are we clear?”

  “Clear.” He didn’t sound too upset. Either Ainsley was one of those kids who didn’t let much bother him or he got yelled at so often, he was immune. “Anything else?”

  “You know the old saying, ‘seeing is believing’?”

  “Yeah, sure.”

  “Well, here’s a clue, it means believing as in faith.”

  Ainsley frowned. “I don’t follow you.”

  “What you see is you, College. Whether you’re looking in a mirror, or at some Amish girl-next-door, whatever you see, describes the inside of you.”

  He took the hint, pulled in his chin, packed the equipment without a word and drove home the same way. Every so often he’d give me a sideways glare.

  He was mulling it over.

  My whole career has been about making pictures that would break enough hearts to change the world. All I ever saw were tragedies.

  7:12:04 p.m.

  Tonya rushed out to meet me as soon as Ainsley pulled into the driveway back at the house. As much as you can rush in heels.

  “Hot date?” I asked, getting out of the truck.

  “We’ll see. Tell you about it next week.” She smiled toward Ainsley but he didn’t bite. “Baby’s out back.” She tossed her evening-knapsack into the backseat of her car and blew me a careful air kiss, so as not to ruin her lipstick. “You watch her close, you hear?”

  “I’m on it.”

  How she folds those long legs, in those high heels, into that midget Escort is an eternal mystery.

  That was all the goodbye I got from either of them. Ainsley roared off.

  The party lights hanging around the living room window were plugged in. The TV was on. I could see everything because I’d pulled the curtains down the day I moved in. Unlike my sister, I never could stand my mother’s old Woolworth’s lace anywhere in sight.

  My father was a drunk. I know most people say alcoholic nowadays, but he was old-fashioned. Drunk suited him. Friday nights, he liked to hit the Pete’s Tap on the way home from work. If he made it to the door, he’d inevitably drop his keys, curl up on the front stoop and nap. In the morning, Mother’d open the door to take in the milk and call, “Come grab his ankles, Magdelena. Let’s get him inside before the neighbors see.” Mom always claimed I got the ankle end because it was lighter. I think it was because half the time he’d pissed himself. Once we’d lugged him inside behind a closed door, she’d go to the window and peek around the lace sheer, checking up and down the street to see if we’d gotten away with it.

  I never put curtains on my windows.

  Once I got inside the house, the first thing I did was check the thermostat. Even living in this house for months, all through the dry blaze of a
midwestern August, walking into the place still made me shiver. It was still my sister’s house-her dopey chili-pepper party lights, her basket of nursing magazines, her crocheted granny blanket over the back of the couch. The place was a hash of hand-me-downs and modest extravagances. Personally, a decent-sized television didn’t count as extravagance, but for her it did.

  The living room walls were thumbtacked with Jenny’s art projects, some so old they’d dried and yellowed at the edge. Fragments would occasionally drop off if someone brushed the wall by accident. Once an entire sheet cracked and crumbled to the ground, a painting of two stick figures and a pair of stick flowers; Jenny cried in her room for hours afterward.

  I walk carefully through this house.

  The light from the television bounced across the unlit living room and gave everything the familiar blue flicker of the electronic hearth. Tonya liked to have the TV on, whether she was in the room, watching or not. She lived alone in a little apartment in Wrigleyville and I suppose the voices and the flickering lights masked neighbor noise and made the place feel lived-in safe. The white noise of the machine did not comfort or bother me. Surrounded by stimulation all day long, the ability to ignore it was part of my job description.

  Jenny had not learned that trick yet. Whenever I saw her cross a room with the TV on, she’d lock eyes on the screen and freeze midstep. My sister had set all kind of rules about television time for her-how much, what channels, what time of day. Those rules had evaporated since I’d arrived. They were ancient history whenever Tonya took the remote in hand. Sometimes Jenny’s reaction bothered me, which was why I’d started getting her to count commercials and promos. I figured she’d grow out of it. I did notice after Tonya spent time with us, Jenny often chose to play on her own out in the yard or in the driveway. Through the glass door to the patio, I looked for Jenny. It was nearly dark outside and colder than it looked. No sign of her. I thought of Rachel. Who would be looking for her as dusk settled?

  I buttoned my jacket and wandered into the backyard. Found her sitting in the birch tree-a big old tree, with papery white bark and leaves that September’s chilly nights had recast in sunlight yellow. In the gloaming, the white tree stood apart from the rest of the yard, melting into the dusk. The thickest bottom branch had grown almost horizontal to the ground. It’d be an easy climber.